SelectQuote Review 2026 (Legit Insurance Quotes?)

Insurance shopping can be overwhelming, but SelectQuote auto insurance reviews suggest that this company can make the process easier.

SelectQuote Rating

SelectQuote helps drivers find the cheapest auto insurance companies in their area. It also offers quotes for life, Medicare, and home insurance.

Despite some shortcomings, SelectQuote has been a trusted source for insurance quotes for four decades. SelectQuote may be a good choice if you’re willing to speak with a representative about your insurance costs.

While SelectQuote insurance quotes are trustworthy, they don’t compare rates with all possible providers. Enter your ZIP code into our comparison tool to save up to 40% on your insurance compared to SelectQuote.

Pros and Cons of SelectQuote

How SelectQuote’s Comparison Tool Works

Like most online quote services, you only need a bit of information and a few minutes to get SelectQuote Medicare, auto, health, life, or home insurance quotes.

The main focus is on SelectQuote life insurance quotes, but you can use the top menu to select the type of insurance you want. You’ll need to provide the following information to see SelectQuote auto insurance quotes:

• ZIP Code: SelectQuote generates auto insurance rates by ZIP code by looking at minimum state requirements and traffic data.
• Insurance History: SelectQuote will ask if you’ve had any car insurance coverage over the last 30 days. If you have had insurance, SelectQuote will ask which provider.
• Driver Demographics: SelectQuote will ask for a few personal details, like your overall credit score and whether you own or rent your home.
• Driving Record: Since your driving record has one of the largest impacts on your premiums, SelectQuote will ask how many accidents, tickets, and insurance claims you’ve had in the last three years.
• Vehicle Information: To get the most accurate quote, SelectQuote will ask how many vehicles you want to insure, how old they are, and what make and model they are.

It only takes a few minutes to answer these questions, but you’ll have to wait to see your quotes. SelectQuote does not provide immediate quote comparisons. Instead, you’ll need to wait for an agent to call you to see your SelectQuote car insurance quotes.

Despite the fact that you have to wait to get quotes, SelectQuote still helps people across the country get the coverage they need. Take a look below to familiarize yourself with SelectQuote a little more before you use its services.

SelectQuote Platform Overview

Regardless of which SelectQuote insurance services you want to take advantage of, you’ll fill out a similar quote request form. The only difference you’ll see is what kind of information you need to provide.

For example, if you want SelectQuote health insurance quotes for supplemental Medicare coverage, you’ll need to answer health-related questions. For SelectQuote home insurance quotes, you’ll see questions about where you live.

SelectQuote Customer Reviews and Complaints

Despite operating since 1985, SelectQuote is not as well-known for insurance quotes as some of its major competitors. For that reason, it doesn’t have as many third-party reviews as many other companies.

Finding the right company to help you choose an auto insurance policy can make the difference between overpaying and getting affordable coverage. SelectQuote may not have many ratings, but what it has is positive. You can check out the few third-party ratings SelectQuote has below.

SelectQuote vs. Insurify vs. NerdWallet: Third-Party Customer Ratings

Based on the few ratings it has, SelectQuote appears to be a reputable company. For example, BBB SelectQuote reviews are largely positive, indicating that the company consistently resolves customer issues.

When it comes to SelectQuote reviews and complaints from actual customers, many are positive. Many customer reviews focus on obtaining affordable life insurance through SelectQuote, more so than for auto coverage.

Others are less than enthusiastic about shopping with the SelectQuote Insurance Agency. Many customers don’t like the high-pressure sales techniques that representatives use over the phone. Some customers have also accused SelectQuote of shady practices, such as this Reddit user.

Beware UnitedHealthcare/Selectquote Scam
byu/billhartzer inHealthInsurance

According to this Reddit user, an elderly relative was tricked into changing her Medicare coverage when she accidentally called SelectQuote instead of UnitedHealthcare.

Other customers on TrustPilot tend to love the service they received from SelectQuote. Consider this TrustPilot user’s review of their experience.

Others, however, were less than pleased. For example, this TrustPilot user was livid about being misled about their future policies.

The second TrustPilot user’s experience is a common complaint found among SelectQuote users. Since SelectQuote is essentially a call center, many users feel sales tactics are too aggressive. There are also complaints that customer service representatives are only friendly before you buy a policy. After, they can be less helpful and harder to reach.

Finally, a frequent complaint is about how many providers SelectQuote works with. For auto insurance quotes, SelectQuote pulls rates from just 18 companies. Many major providers, including Geico, Allstate, Nationwide, and State Farm, do not work with SelectQuote.

SelectQuote vs. Competitors: Who to Trust

There are a few other companies where you might find affordable quotes for a variety of types of auto insurance coverage.

If you’d prefer instance quotes, you can see prices in under two minutes with AutoInsurance. You’ll also get quotes from 25% more providers than you would with SelectQuote. Enter your ZIP code into our free quote tool to compare rates from top providers fast.

However, these aren’t the only two quote comparison sites. Before you get quotes from SelectQuote, consider the following companies.

SelectQuote vs. Insurify

SelectQuote and Insurify are similar in many ways, including offering an easy way to compare multiple quotes for a variety of insurance types.

However, while SelectQuote offers quotes for car, home, life, and Medicare coverage, you can get quotes for the following with Insurify:

• Auto
• Home
• Renters
• Pet

While they work in similar ways, Insurify offers more variety in its quotes. Where SelectQuote retrieves quotes from 18 car insurance companies, Insurify works with over 120. Check out our Insurify auto insurance review to learn more about this virtual agent.

SelectQuote vs. The Zebra

The Zebra works similarly to SelectQuote, but you’ll see most of your quotes immediately with The Zebra. With The Zebra, you can view quotes for the following types of insurance:

• Auto
• Home
• Renters
• Pet
• Life

The Zebra also works with Progressive to offer easy quotes for a variety of policies, like commercial auto, motorcycle, and RV insurance. However, there are plenty of pros and cons with The Zebra, just like SelectQuote.

You can learn more about these pros and cons in our auto insurance review for The Zebra. Aside from pros and cons, one of the features that sets The Zebra apart from SelectQuote the most is its coverage comparison tool. When you receive a quote, you can select the amount of coverage you need, whether it’s liability-only or a full coverage policy.

While The Zebra is a good choice for comparing auto insurance quotes, drivers should be cautious. Many customers report an excessive amount of spam after using The Zebra for their insurance needs.

Who Should Try SelectQuote Insurance Services

Learning how to compare multiple insurance quotes is crucial to finding affordable rates, and SelectQuote offers a decent tool to help.

However, it should only be used by drivers who are comfortable speaking with a sales representative before purchasing their policy.

With so many options, finding the best🏆auto insurance company can seem overwhelming 😓. At https://t.co/27f1xf1ARb, we’ve compiled info, compared companies, and shared the results. Check out our comparison here 👉: https://t.co/QOSZYLmTsa pic.twitter.com/5p59WG7nJy

— AutoInsurance.org (@AutoInsurance) June 5, 2023

If waiting around for a phone call from a representative using high-pressure sales tactics doesn’t sound like an ideal way to find insurance, you can always use our free comparison tool by entering your ZIP code. Not only will you get quotes in under two minutes, but you’ll also have access to 25% more providers than you would with SelectQuote.